Tier 3+1
Beyond Consciousness
Jeff Vander Clute Radiant Organizations
Fundamental Differences Between Tier 1 and Tier 2
Core Shifts in Consciousness
Tier 1 (Beige through Green)
- Operating System: Subsistence-based values
- Self-Identity: Individual/group identification
- Perspective: Each level sees itself as the "correct" way
- Problem-Solving: Solutions from within current level
- Integration: Tends to reject other levels
- Change: Driven by external problems/challenges
- Motivation: Deficiency needs (survival, belonging, achievement)
Tier 2 (Yellow/Teal through Turquoise)
- Operating System: Being-based values
- Self-Identity: Systemic/holistic identification
- Perspective: Recognizes validity of all levels
- Problem-Solving: Can access solutions from any level
- Integration: Integrates and utilizes all previous levels
- Change: Driven by internal development/evolution
- Motivation: Self-actualization and transcendence
Key Transition Markers from Tier 1 to Tier 2
1. Meta-Cognitive Leap
- From: Operating within systems
- To: Understanding systems of systems
2. Identity Expansion
- From: Individual/group-based identity
- To: Recognition of self as part of larger living systems
3. Value Integration
- From: Competing value systems
- To: Nested holarchy of values
4. Problem-Solving Approach
- From: Linear/single-level solutions
- To: Dynamic/multi-level solutions
5. Relationship to Change
- From: Resistance/reaction to change
- To: Co-evolution with change
Requirements for Defining a New Tier
Based on the Tier 1 to Tier 2 transition, we can propose that a new tier would need to demonstrate:
1. A fundamental shift in consciousness as significant as the move from subsistence to being-values
2. A qualitatively different way of knowing and processing reality
3. Novel capacities that transcend and include previous tier capabilities
4. A distinct shift in how identity and self are experienced
5. A fundamentally new relationship with existence/reality
Analysis of Vander Clute's Advanced Stages
Progressive Evolution Beyond Teal
Turquoise Stage
- Still operates within Tier 2 framework
- Deepens Teal capacities through:
- Enhanced collective awareness
- Transpersonal understanding
- Generative space holding
- Represents evolution within Tier 2, not a new tier
Coral Stage
- Shows potential transition characteristics:
- Shift from doing to "sourcing"
- Collective awakening as superorganism
- Transcendence of individual agency
- May represent bridge between Tier 2 and Tier 3
Clear Light Stage
Potential Tier 3 Markers:
1. Fundamental Consciousness Shift
- From: Being-based consciousness
- To: Non-dual awareness beyond being/becoming
2. New Way of Knowing
- From: Integrative understanding
- To: Direct perception of reality
3. Novel Capacities
- Transcendence of developmental stages
- "Accomplishing via nondoing"
- Absolute fluidity of form
4. Identity Shift
- From: Holistic self
- To: No-self/all-self simultaneity
5. New Relationship with Reality
- From: Co-evolution with reality
- To: Identity with ground of being
Beyond Clear Light
- Being Nature
- BEING SOURCE
- THE SUPREME
These stages appear to represent further evolution within what could be considered Tier 3, rather than additional tiers.
Assessment
Based on our tier transition criteria, Clear Light appears to represent a genuine tier shift because:
1. It demonstrates a fundamental shift in consciousness beyond being-values to non-dual awareness
2. It introduces a qualitatively different way of knowing through direct perception
3. It manifests novel capacities that transcend and include previous tiers
4. It represents a distinct shift in identity beyond the holistic self
5. It establishes a fundamentally new relationship with reality as identity with the ground of being
Therefore, Vander Clute's model suggests:
- Turquoise: Advanced Tier 2
- Coral: Transition stage
- Clear Light and beyond: Potential Tier 3
Theoretical Frameworks for Post-Turquoise Development
Comparative Analysis of Major Frameworks
1. Traditional Spiral Dynamics (Beck & Cowan)
- Terminal Stage: Turquoise
- Key Features:
- Holistic life system
- Global networking
- Universal spirituality
- Limitations:
- Does not extensively explore beyond Turquoise
- Focused primarily on cognitive/values development
2. Integral Theory (Wilber)
- Stages Beyond Turquoise:
- Indigo: Unity consciousness
- Violet: Illumined mind
- Ultraviolet: Overmind
- Key Features:
- Integration of states and stages
- Emphasis on spiritual development
- Multiple lines of development
- Contribution:
- Links developmental psychology with contemplative traditions
- Suggests possibility of further evolution
3. Vander Clute's Model
- Stages Beyond Turquoise:
- Coral
- Clear Light
- Being Nature
- BEING SOURCE
- THE SUPREME
- Key Features:
- Emphasis on collective consciousness
- Integration of organizational and spiritual development
- Transcendence of individual/collective divide
- Unique Contributions:
- Focus on organizational embodiment
- Connection to source consciousness
- Practical frameworks for implementation
4. Action Logics (Torbert)
- Advanced Stages:
- Alchemist
- Ironist
- Key Features:
- Integration of awareness and action
- Transformation of self and systems
- Time-awareness across multiple scales
Patterns Across Frameworks
Common Themes
1. Transcendence of Individual Identity
- All frameworks point to dissolution of separate self
- Movement toward universal/cosmic identity
2. Integration of Polarities
- Resolution of fundamental dualities
- Both/and thinking becomes being
3. Direct Knowing
- Shift from conceptual to immediate understanding
- Access to transpersonal wisdom
4. Collective Evolution
- Movement beyond individual development
- Emergence of group/organizational consciousness
Key Differences
1. Scope
- Some focus on individual development
- Others emphasize collective/organizational evolution
- Varying emphasis on spiritual vs. practical manifestation
2. Terminal Points
- Different views on ultimate development
- Varying perspectives on what's possible/attainable
3. Methodology
- Different approaches to verification
- Varying emphasis on empirical vs. phenomenological evidence
Synthesis of Frameworks
Potential Tier 3 Characteristics
1. Consciousness:
- Beyond integration to direct realization
- Non-dual awareness as default
2. Agency:
- Transcendence of individual/collective divide
- Spontaneous right action without doer
3. Knowledge:
- Direct perception of reality
- Access to source wisdom
4. Organization:
- Self-aware superorganisms
- Natural alignment with universal principles
5. Evolution:
- Self-transcendence becomes automatic
- Development beyond development
Analysis of Higher Stage Characteristics
Empirical Considerations
Observable Markers
1. Individual Level
- Consistent non-dual awareness
- Spontaneous right action
- Absence of personal reactivity
- Universal compassion
2. Organizational Level
- Collective coherence
- Emergent wisdom
- Effortless effectiveness
- Natural alignment with life
Challenges in Verification
1. Measurement Issues
- Subjective nature of experiences
- Lack of standardized assessment tools
- Difficulty distinguishing states from stages
2. Developmental Considerations
- Rarity of advanced development
- Limited longitudinal data
- Cultural context variations
Evidence Types
1. Phenomenological Reports
- Mystic traditions
- Contemporary practitioners
- Organizational case studies
2. Behavioral Indicators
- Decision-making patterns
- Response to challenges
- Leadership characteristics
3. Collective Manifestations
- Group coherence
- Organizational outcomes
- Social impact
Key Questions and Implications
Theoretical Questions
1. Nature of Development
- Is there an end to development?
- How do individual and collective development interact?
- What role does consciousness play?
2. Verification
- How can we verify these stages?
- What constitutes evidence?
- How do we distinguish authentic development?
Practical Implications
1. Individual Development
- Practices for cultivation
- Integration challenges
- Support structures needed
2. Organizational Development
- Leadership requirements
- Cultural conditions
- Structural adaptations
3. Societal Impact
- Potential for transformation
- Ecological considerations
- Global implications
Research Directions
Needed Studies
1. Longitudinal tracking of advanced practitioners
2. Organizational case studies
3. Cross-cultural validation
4. Development of assessment tools
Methodological Approaches
1. Mixed-methods research
2. Phenomenological investigation
3. Action research
4. Systems analysis
Tier 3 Consciousness: Beyond Integration to Source Realization
Executive Summary
This paper proposes a theoretical framework for understanding Tier 3 consciousness, building on Spiral Dynamics and integrating insights from multiple developmental frameworks, particularly Jeff Vander Clute's work on Clear Light organizations. We argue that Tier 3 represents a fundamental shift beyond both the subsistence-based values of Tier 1 and the being-based values of Tier 2, into what we might call "source-based" consciousness.
I. Defining Characteristics of Tier 3
A. Fundamental Shifts
1. Consciousness Structure
- Tier 1: Subsistence-based (survival, belonging, achievement)
- Tier 2: Being-based (integration, systems thinking, holistic awareness)
- Tier 3: Source-based (direct realization, non-dual awareness, spontaneous right action)
2. Operating System
- From: Systems thinking and integration (Tier 2)
- To: Direct perception and embodiment of source consciousness
3. Identity
- From: Holistic self-sense (Tier 2)
- To: Simultaneous individual/universal identity
B. Key Markers
1. Transcendence of Development
- Beyond staged progression
- Natural unfoldment rather than structured evolution
- Development beyond development
2. Collective Consciousness
- Emergence of genuine superorganisms
- Spontaneous collective coherence
- Direct access to universal intelligence
3. Action and Agency
- "Accomplishing via nondoing"
- Spontaneous right action without doer
- Natural alignment with universal principles
II. Theoretical Framework
A. Stages Within Tier 3
1. Entry Stage (Coral-like)
- Bridge from Tier 2
- Beginning of collective awakening
- Initial transcendence of individual agency
2. Stabilization Stage (Clear Light-like)
- Full embodiment of non-dual awareness
- Consistent access to source consciousness
- Fluid movement between individual and collective identity
3. Advanced Stages (Being Nature/Source)
- Complete integration with natural systems
- Direct embodiment of source consciousness
- Universal creativity and agency
B. Distinguishing Features from Tier 2
1. Relationship to Reality
- Tier 2: Understanding and working with systems
- Tier 3: Identity with the ground of being
2. Problem-Solving
- Tier 2: Integration of multiple perspectives
- Tier 3: Direct perception of optimal action
3. Evolution
- Tier 2: Conscious development
- Tier 3: Spontaneous unfoldment
III. Evidence and Verification
A. Observable Indicators
1. Individual Level
- Consistent non-dual awareness
- Absence of personal reactivity
- Spontaneous compassionate action
- Direct knowing
2. Organizational Level
- Collective coherence
- Effortless effectiveness
- Natural alignment with life systems
- Emergent wisdom
B. Methodological Challenges
1. Measurement
- Limited conventional metrics
- Need for new assessment approaches
- Challenge of subjective verification
2. Validation
- Rarity of examples
- Cultural context variations
- State vs. stage distinctions
IV. Practical Implications
A. Development
1. Individual Practices
- Cultivation of non-dual awareness
- Integration of transcendent experiences
- Development of direct perception
2. Organizational Approaches
- Creating conditions for collective awakening
- Supporting emergent processes
- Fostering natural alignment
B. Applications
1. Leadership
- Beyond hierarchical structures
- Facilitation of collective intelligence
- Stewardship of emergence
2. Social Impact
- Addressing complex global challenges
- Facilitating societal evolution
- Environmental restoration
V. Future Research Directions
1. Empirical Studies
- Longitudinal tracking of advanced practitioners
- Organizational case studies
- Development of assessment tools
2. Theoretical Development
- Integration with other frameworks
- Cross-cultural validation
- Refinement of stage descriptions
3. Practical Applications
- Development methodologies
- Organizational structures
- Leadership approaches
VI. Conclusions
Tier 3 consciousness represents a fundamental shift beyond both the subsistence-based values of Tier 1 and the being-based values of Tier 2. It is characterized by direct source realization, spontaneous right action, and the emergence of genuine collective consciousness. While challenging to verify and measure, evidence suggests this level of development is both possible and increasingly relevant to addressing contemporary global challenges.
The emergence of Tier 3 consciousness may represent humanity's next major evolutionary step, offering new possibilities for addressing complex global challenges through advanced forms of collective intelligence and direct knowing. However, further research and practical experimentation are needed to fully understand and facilitate this development.
Beyond the Known: The Emergence of Tier 3 Consciousness
Concluding Synthesis
Our comprehensive exploration of development beyond Spiral Dynamics' traditional framework reveals a fascinating possibility: the emergence of what we might call Tier 3 consciousness represents not just another step in human evolution, but a quantum leap into fundamentally new territory. While Tier 1 consciousness dealt with survival and subsistence, and Tier 2 brought integration and systemic awareness, Tier 3 appears to transcend the very framework of developmental stages itself.
The evidence for this leap comes from multiple directions: the theoretical work of Clare Graves and Don Beck, Ken Wilber's integral insights, and particularly Jeff Vander Clute's groundbreaking research into Clear Light organizations. What emerges is a picture of consciousness that moves beyond both individual and collective paradigms into what might be called "source realization" - a state of being where the boundaries between individual, organization, and universal consciousness become increasingly fluid.
Yet this is not merely theoretical. We see early signs of this emergence in organizations and individuals who demonstrate capabilities previously thought impossible: spontaneous collective wisdom, action without actor, and direct knowing that transcends traditional decision-making processes. These capabilities suggest that humanity may be standing at the threshold of an evolutionary leap as significant as the development of self-reflective consciousness itself.
Implications and Possibilities
The implications are profound. If Tier 3 consciousness is indeed emerging, it offers new possibilities for addressing the complex challenges facing humanity. Climate change, social inequality, and other "wicked problems" may become tractable not through better problem-solving methods, but through a fundamental shift in how we relate to reality itself. Organizations operating at this level could become agents of planetary healing and evolution in ways we can barely imagine.
However, this research also reveals the humbling truth that our current frameworks and language may be inadequate to fully describe or understand these emerging possibilities. Like trying to explain color to someone who has never seen, we may be reaching the limits of what can be conveyed through traditional academic discourse.
Looking Forward
As we look to the future, several key questions emerge:
1. How can we create conditions conducive to the emergence of Tier 3 consciousness?
2. What role might technology play in supporting this evolution?
3. How do we balance the rigors of academic research with the inherently transcendent nature of these developments?
Perhaps most importantly: How do we remain open to possibilities that transcend our current understanding while maintaining scientific integrity?
What seems clear is that we are witnessing the early stages of a profound shift in human consciousness. Whether we call it Tier 3, Clear Light, or something else entirely, this emergence represents both a challenge and an opportunity. It challenges our assumptions about the nature of development, consciousness, and reality itself. And it offers the possibility of new ways of being, knowing, and doing that could help humanity navigate the complex challenges of our time.
The journey into Tier 3 consciousness is not just an intellectual exploration but an invitation to participate in humanity's next evolutionary leap. As we stand at this threshold, we are called to hold both rigorous skepticism and radical openness - to be willing to question everything we think we know while remaining open to possibilities beyond our current imagination.
In the end, perhaps this is the greatest gift of researching Tier 3 consciousness: it reminds us that the universe is far more mysterious and full of potential than we have yet dreamed, and that humanity's journey of development is far from complete.
I have issues with this. Mostly the supreme part. I am a massive anti supremecist in all its forms even in the for where the word is apparrently being used for good. Nothing good comes from a supreme mindset.